Ins & Outs of Software Testing Technology Under One Roof
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Certifications Resources
    • HP QTP Certifications
    • PMI PMP Certification Preparation
    • PMI PMP Certification Exam Practice Question Papers
    • CSTE Certifications
    • IBM RFT Certification
    • ISTQB Certifications
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Manager Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Analysts Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Level Exam Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Exam - Sample Question Papers
    • ISTQB Agile Tester Extension Exam
    • ISTQB Advanced Test Managers Exam Preparation
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Exam Preparation
  • Knowledge Center
    • Career Building in Testing
      • Qualities of Test Personnel
      • Career Shaping in QA
    • Interview Preparation - FAQ
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of QTP in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of LoadRunner in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Common HR Questions
      • FAQ - Tricky HR Questions
      • FAQ - Software Testing and QA
      • FAQ - QTP - Quick Test Professional
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Controller)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (VuGen)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Basics)
      • FAQ - RFT - Rational Functional Tester
      • FAQ - Database Testing
      • FAQ - Silk Test
    • Flamboyant Topics
      • Software Bugs
      • White Box Testing
      • Gray Box Testing
      • Black Box Testing
      • Website Testing
      • Database Testing
      • SDLC & STLC
      • Risk Analysis
      • Test Cases
      • Software Development Models
      • Achievements
    • QA Best Practices
      • Software Testing - General
    • New Technologies
      • Robotic Process Automation
      • Big Data
    • Glossary Encyclopedia
      • Encyclopedia - Software Testing Terms
      • Glossary Encyclopedia - Linked articles
    • Favorite Industry Topics
      • Global Recession
  • Automation Testing
    • Automation Testing
      • Review your RFT Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M49 Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M48 Skills
      • Review your Performance Center HPO-M47 Skills
      • Review Your HP QTP / UFT Skills
      • Review Your Quality Center Skills
      • Automation Frameworks
      • Ins & Outs of Automation
    • Hot Automation Tools
      • Selenium
      • Selenium WebDriver
      • Selenium IDE
      • Katalon Studio
      • IBM Rational Functional Tester
      • HP LoadRunner
      • HP WinRunner
      • HP Quality Center
      • HP Quick Test Professional / UFT
      • Functional Testing Tools - Linked Articles
  • Manual Testing
    • Manual Testing
      • Various Approaches
      • Test Planning
    • Software Testing Startup Kit
      • Startup Articles
      • Basics of Testing
      • Quality Perspective
      • Types of Testing
      • Testing Tools
      • Types of Software Testing - Linked Articles
    • Quality Systems
      • QA Managers Skill Test
      • Software Testing Skill Test
      • Quality Management
      • CMM & CMMI
      • Verification & Validation (V&V)
      • Quality Perspective - Linked Articles
    • Templates & Checklists
      • Templates for Download
      • Checklists for Testers & Developers
      • Checklists for QA Managers & Team Leads
  • Tutorials
    • Tutorials: HP QTP / UFT
    • Tutorials: HP LoadRunner
    • Tutorials: IBM Rational Functional Tester
  • Quizes
    • HP QC Expert Level Quiz
    • QTP Basic Level Quiz
    • QTP Intermediate Level Quiz
    • QTP Expert Level Quiz
    • RFT - Rational Functional Tester Quiz
    • Software Testing Basics Quiz
    • ISTQB Certification Quiz
    • CSTE Certification Quiz
  • Free eBooks
    • eBooks: HP QTP/UFT
    • eBooks: Manual Testing
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Certifications Resources
    • HP QTP Certifications
    • PMI PMP Certification Preparation
    • PMI PMP Certification Exam Practice Question Papers
    • CSTE Certifications
    • IBM RFT Certification
    • ISTQB Certifications
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Manager Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Analysts Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Level Exam Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Exam - Sample Question Papers
    • ISTQB Agile Tester Extension Exam
    • ISTQB Advanced Test Managers Exam Preparation
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Exam Preparation
  • Knowledge Center
    • Career Building in Testing
      • Qualities of Test Personnel
      • Career Shaping in QA
    • Interview Preparation - FAQ
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of QTP in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of LoadRunner in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Common HR Questions
      • FAQ - Tricky HR Questions
      • FAQ - Software Testing and QA
      • FAQ - QTP - Quick Test Professional
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Controller)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (VuGen)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Basics)
      • FAQ - RFT - Rational Functional Tester
      • FAQ - Database Testing
      • FAQ - Silk Test
    • Flamboyant Topics
      • Software Bugs
      • White Box Testing
      • Gray Box Testing
      • Black Box Testing
      • Website Testing
      • Database Testing
      • SDLC & STLC
      • Risk Analysis
      • Test Cases
      • Software Development Models
      • Achievements
    • QA Best Practices
      • Software Testing - General
    • New Technologies
      • Robotic Process Automation
      • Big Data
    • Glossary Encyclopedia
      • Encyclopedia - Software Testing Terms
      • Glossary Encyclopedia - Linked articles
    • Favorite Industry Topics
      • Global Recession
  • Automation Testing
    • Automation Testing
      • Review your RFT Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M49 Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M48 Skills
      • Review your Performance Center HPO-M47 Skills
      • Review Your HP QTP / UFT Skills
      • Review Your Quality Center Skills
      • Automation Frameworks
      • Ins & Outs of Automation
    • Hot Automation Tools
      • Selenium
      • Selenium WebDriver
      • Selenium IDE
      • Katalon Studio
      • IBM Rational Functional Tester
      • HP LoadRunner
      • HP WinRunner
      • HP Quality Center
      • HP Quick Test Professional / UFT
      • Functional Testing Tools - Linked Articles
  • Manual Testing
    • Manual Testing
      • Various Approaches
      • Test Planning
    • Software Testing Startup Kit
      • Startup Articles
      • Basics of Testing
      • Quality Perspective
      • Types of Testing
      • Testing Tools
      • Types of Software Testing - Linked Articles
    • Quality Systems
      • QA Managers Skill Test
      • Software Testing Skill Test
      • Quality Management
      • CMM & CMMI
      • Verification & Validation (V&V)
      • Quality Perspective - Linked Articles
    • Templates & Checklists
      • Templates for Download
      • Checklists for Testers & Developers
      • Checklists for QA Managers & Team Leads
  • Tutorials
    • Tutorials: HP QTP / UFT
    • Tutorials: HP LoadRunner
    • Tutorials: IBM Rational Functional Tester
  • Quizes
    • HP QC Expert Level Quiz
    • QTP Basic Level Quiz
    • QTP Intermediate Level Quiz
    • QTP Expert Level Quiz
    • RFT - Rational Functional Tester Quiz
    • Software Testing Basics Quiz
    • ISTQB Certification Quiz
    • CSTE Certification Quiz
  • Free eBooks
    • eBooks: HP QTP/UFT
    • eBooks: Manual Testing
Ins & Outs of Software Testing Technology Under One Roof
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Certifications Resources
    • HP QTP Certifications
    • PMI PMP Certification Preparation
    • PMI PMP Certification Exam Practice Question Papers
    • CSTE Certifications
    • IBM RFT Certification
    • ISTQB Certifications
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Manager Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Analysts Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Level Exam Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Exam - Sample Question Papers
    • ISTQB Agile Tester Extension Exam
    • ISTQB Advanced Test Managers Exam Preparation
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Exam Preparation
  • Knowledge Center
    • Career Building in Testing
      • Qualities of Test Personnel
      • Career Shaping in QA
    • Interview Preparation - FAQ
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of QTP in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of LoadRunner in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Common HR Questions
      • FAQ - Tricky HR Questions
      • FAQ - Software Testing and QA
      • FAQ - QTP - Quick Test Professional
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Controller)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (VuGen)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Basics)
      • FAQ - RFT - Rational Functional Tester
      • FAQ - Database Testing
      • FAQ - Silk Test
    • Flamboyant Topics
      • Software Bugs
      • White Box Testing
      • Gray Box Testing
      • Black Box Testing
      • Website Testing
      • Database Testing
      • SDLC & STLC
      • Risk Analysis
      • Test Cases
      • Software Development Models
      • Achievements
    • QA Best Practices
      • Software Testing - General
    • New Technologies
      • Robotic Process Automation
      • Big Data
    • Glossary Encyclopedia
      • Encyclopedia - Software Testing Terms
      • Glossary Encyclopedia - Linked articles
    • Favorite Industry Topics
      • Global Recession
  • Automation Testing
    • Automation Testing
      • Review your RFT Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M49 Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M48 Skills
      • Review your Performance Center HPO-M47 Skills
      • Review Your HP QTP / UFT Skills
      • Review Your Quality Center Skills
      • Automation Frameworks
      • Ins & Outs of Automation
    • Hot Automation Tools
      • Selenium
      • Selenium WebDriver
      • Selenium IDE
      • Katalon Studio
      • IBM Rational Functional Tester
      • HP LoadRunner
      • HP WinRunner
      • HP Quality Center
      • HP Quick Test Professional / UFT
      • Functional Testing Tools - Linked Articles
  • Manual Testing
    • Manual Testing
      • Various Approaches
      • Test Planning
    • Software Testing Startup Kit
      • Startup Articles
      • Basics of Testing
      • Quality Perspective
      • Types of Testing
      • Testing Tools
      • Types of Software Testing - Linked Articles
    • Quality Systems
      • QA Managers Skill Test
      • Software Testing Skill Test
      • Quality Management
      • CMM & CMMI
      • Verification & Validation (V&V)
      • Quality Perspective - Linked Articles
    • Templates & Checklists
      • Templates for Download
      • Checklists for Testers & Developers
      • Checklists for QA Managers & Team Leads
  • Tutorials
    • Tutorials: HP QTP / UFT
    • Tutorials: HP LoadRunner
    • Tutorials: IBM Rational Functional Tester
  • Quizes
    • HP QC Expert Level Quiz
    • QTP Basic Level Quiz
    • QTP Intermediate Level Quiz
    • QTP Expert Level Quiz
    • RFT - Rational Functional Tester Quiz
    • Software Testing Basics Quiz
    • ISTQB Certification Quiz
    • CSTE Certification Quiz
  • Free eBooks
    • eBooks: HP QTP/UFT
    • eBooks: Manual Testing
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Certifications Resources
    • HP QTP Certifications
    • PMI PMP Certification Preparation
    • PMI PMP Certification Exam Practice Question Papers
    • CSTE Certifications
    • IBM RFT Certification
    • ISTQB Certifications
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Manager Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Test Analysts Exam-Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Level Exam Crash Course
    • ISTQB Foundation Exam - Sample Question Papers
    • ISTQB Agile Tester Extension Exam
    • ISTQB Advanced Test Managers Exam Preparation
    • ISTQB Advanced CTAL Exam Preparation
  • Knowledge Center
    • Career Building in Testing
      • Qualities of Test Personnel
      • Career Shaping in QA
    • Interview Preparation - FAQ
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of QTP in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Rehearsal of LoadRunner in 1 Hr.
      • FAQ - Common HR Questions
      • FAQ - Tricky HR Questions
      • FAQ - Software Testing and QA
      • FAQ - QTP - Quick Test Professional
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Controller)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (VuGen)
      • FAQ - HP Load Runner (Basics)
      • FAQ - RFT - Rational Functional Tester
      • FAQ - Database Testing
      • FAQ - Silk Test
    • Flamboyant Topics
      • Software Bugs
      • White Box Testing
      • Gray Box Testing
      • Black Box Testing
      • Website Testing
      • Database Testing
      • SDLC & STLC
      • Risk Analysis
      • Test Cases
      • Software Development Models
      • Achievements
    • QA Best Practices
      • Software Testing - General
    • New Technologies
      • Robotic Process Automation
      • Big Data
    • Glossary Encyclopedia
      • Encyclopedia - Software Testing Terms
      • Glossary Encyclopedia - Linked articles
    • Favorite Industry Topics
      • Global Recession
  • Automation Testing
    • Automation Testing
      • Review your RFT Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M49 Skills
      • Review your LoadRunner HPO-M48 Skills
      • Review your Performance Center HPO-M47 Skills
      • Review Your HP QTP / UFT Skills
      • Review Your Quality Center Skills
      • Automation Frameworks
      • Ins & Outs of Automation
    • Hot Automation Tools
      • Selenium
      • Selenium WebDriver
      • Selenium IDE
      • Katalon Studio
      • IBM Rational Functional Tester
      • HP LoadRunner
      • HP WinRunner
      • HP Quality Center
      • HP Quick Test Professional / UFT
      • Functional Testing Tools - Linked Articles
  • Manual Testing
    • Manual Testing
      • Various Approaches
      • Test Planning
    • Software Testing Startup Kit
      • Startup Articles
      • Basics of Testing
      • Quality Perspective
      • Types of Testing
      • Testing Tools
      • Types of Software Testing - Linked Articles
    • Quality Systems
      • QA Managers Skill Test
      • Software Testing Skill Test
      • Quality Management
      • CMM & CMMI
      • Verification & Validation (V&V)
      • Quality Perspective - Linked Articles
    • Templates & Checklists
      • Templates for Download
      • Checklists for Testers & Developers
      • Checklists for QA Managers & Team Leads
  • Tutorials
    • Tutorials: HP QTP / UFT
    • Tutorials: HP LoadRunner
    • Tutorials: IBM Rational Functional Tester
  • Quizes
    • HP QC Expert Level Quiz
    • QTP Basic Level Quiz
    • QTP Intermediate Level Quiz
    • QTP Expert Level Quiz
    • RFT - Rational Functional Tester Quiz
    • Software Testing Basics Quiz
    • ISTQB Certification Quiz
    • CSTE Certification Quiz
  • Free eBooks
    • eBooks: HP QTP/UFT
    • eBooks: Manual Testing
Home > Blog > Knowledge Center > Flamboyant Topics > Black Box Testing > Comparison among various Black Box or Functional Software Testing Techniques

Comparison among various Black Box or Functional Software Testing Techniques

Sign up to receive Regular updates via email or RSS!

Type your email address and press Enter

Quick Links

  • Free Updates
  • Write & Earn
  • Quick Navigation Sitemap
  • ISTQB Certification
  • QTP Certifications

Advertisements

Comparison among various Black Box or Functional Software Testing Techniques

Posted in: Black Box Testing
Leave a comment


Comparison among various Black Box or Functional Software Testing Techniques


Testing Effort

The functional methods vary both in terms of the number of test cases generated and the effort to develop these test cases. To compare the three techniques, namely, boundary value analysis (BVA), equivalence class partitioning and decision table based technique let us focus our attention on  the following graph.

 

Number of test cases

The domain-based techniques have no recognition of data or logical dependencies. They are very mechanical in the way they generate test cases. Because of this, they are also easy to automate. The techniques like equivalence class testing focus on data dependencies and thus we need to demonstrate our skill. The thinking goes into the identification of the equivalence classes and after that, the process is mechanical. It may be noted from the graph, that the decision table based technique is most sophisticated because it requires the tester to consider both data and logical dependencies. It may be seen that once we get a good and healthy set of conditions, the resulting test cases are complete and minimal.

Now, consider another graph to show the effort required to identify the test cases versus its sophistication.

 

effort required to identify the test cases

Thus we can say that the effort required to identify test cases is lowest in BVA and highest in decision tables. The end result is a trade-off between the test case effort identification and test case execution effort. If we shift our effort toward more sophisticated testing methods, we reduce our test execution time. This is very important as tests are usually executed several times. It may be noted that, judging testing quality in terms of the sheer number of test cases has drawbacks similar to judging programming productivity in terms of lines of code.


Effect of various Testing Stretegies on Testing Efficiency:

It is evident from all the abobve mentioned functional testing strategies that either the functionality is untested or the test cases are redundant. So, gaps do occur in functional test cases and these gaps are reduced by using more sophisticated techniques.

We can develop various ratios of total number of test cases generated by method-A to those generated by method-B or even ratios on a test case basis. This is more difficult but sometimes the management may demand numbers even when they have little real meaning. When we see several test cases with the same purpose, sense redundancy, detecting the gaps is quite difficult. If we use only functional testing, the best we can do is to compare the test cases that result from two methods. In general, the more sophisticated method will help us recognize gaps but nothing is guaranted.


How to measure Testing Effectiveness of these Testing Techniques:

 


The easiest choice is

 


1) Be Dogmatic:
 We can select a method, use it to generate test cases and then run the test cases. We can improve on this by not being dogmatic and allowing the tester to choose the most appropriate method. We can gain another incremental improvement by devising appropriate hybrid methods.

 

2) The second choice can be the structural testing techniques for the test effectiveness.

It may be noted that the best interpretation for testing effectiveness is most difficult. We would like to know how effective a set of test cases is for finding faults present in a program. This is problematic due to the following two reasons.

 

1) It presumes that we are aware of the faults in a program.

 

2) Proving that a program is fault-free is equivalent to the famous halting problem of computer science, which is known to be impossible.

 


Then What is the Best Solution ?

 

The best solution is to work backward from fault types. Given a particular kind of fault, we can choose testing methods (functional and structural) that are likely to reveal faults of that type. If we couple this with knowledge of the most likely kinds of faults, we end up with a pragamatic approach to testing effectiveness. This is improved if we track the kinds of faults and their frequencies in the software we develop.


Key Guidelines for the Functional Testing

 

1) If the variables refer to physical quantities then domain testing and equivalence class testing should be used.

2) If the variables are independent then domain testing and equivalence class testing should be used.

3) If the variables are dependent, decision table testing should be practiced.

 

4) If the single-fault assumption is warranted then BVA and robustness testing should be used.

 

5) If the multiple-fault assumption is warranted then worst case testing, robust worst case testing and decision table based testing should be practiced.

 

6) If the program has significant exception handling, robustness testing and decision table based testing are identical.

 

7) If the variable refers to logical quantities, equivalence class testing and decision table testing should be practiced.

Many More Articles & Tutorials on Black Box Testing

Yogindernath Gupta

An expert on R&D, Online Training and Publishing. He is M.Tech. (Honours) and is a part of the STG team since inception.

See author's posts

Sharing is caring
Posted in Black Box Testing, Flamboyant Topics

Post navigation

Previous post
How to compare Web Application and Normal Software Project
Next post
Review your Skills on Wesite Testing-through Objective Type Questions

WP Post Author

Yogindernath Gupta

An expert on R&D, Online Training and Publishing. He is M.Tech. (Honours) and is a part of the STG team since inception.

See author's posts

Quick Links to Our Knowledgebase
Interview Preparation
Interview Preparation Resources for Beginners to Experts
PMI PMP (Project Management Professional) Certification
PMI PMP Certification Préparation Ressources
PMI PMP Certification Exam Practice Question Papers
Study Material for ISTQB Certifications
Study Material - ISTQB Certified Tester Foundation Level Exam
Study Material - ISTQB Agile Tester Extension Level Exam
Study Material - ISTQB Certified Tester Advanced Level - All 3 Certifications
Keep track of latest posts by subscribing our RSS feed.You can also Subscribe by E-mail and get All New articles delivered directly to your Inbox.
Study Material for CSTE Certification
Complete Study Material-Certified Software Test Engineer-CSTE Certification Exam
Certifications on Reputed Automation Tools
Study Material - HP QTP / UFT Certification Exam
Study Material - HP QC / ALM Certification Exam
Study Material - HP LoadRunner Certification Exam
Study Material - IBM Rational Functional Tester - RFT Certification Exam
Quick Navigation Sitemap of SoftwareTestingGenius

Get your Absolutely Free Copy of Several Presentations & E-Books related to ISTQB, HP QTP/UFT, Load Runner, RFT and many more Certification Exams, prepared by Expert & Trainers, by writing to: Software.testing.genius@gmail.com

Advertisements

About Us
Know more about Software Testing Genius!
Contact Us
Start a conversation with our team of experts!
Easy Navigation Sitemap
Quickly navigate through Software Testing Genius!

Privacy Policy
Copyright Policy
Online Conduct

Advertise
Promote your Website, Product or Services!
QTP/UFT Training
Get Online Training From HP Certified Experts!
Software Testing Service
Outsource your testing requirements to us!
Connect with us
Latest Posts
  • What Software Testers can do to Prepare for the Next Recession?
  • Journey of Selenium – a Primer
  • Comparison between QTP/UFT and Selenium – the pros & cons of both
  • An Insight to Project Management – A Short Primer for Novice to Experts
  • New Techniques emerging out of the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Free & Best Study Material

  • ISTQB Certification Foundation & Advanced
  • QTP Certification (UFT 11.5) & ALM
  • HP Load Runner 12.x
  • IBM Rational Functional Tester (000-842)

Copyscape Protection

Copyright © 2008 - 2023 Software Testing Genius

Web Cohort: Corporate Network Executions